Dear Air Chief Marshal Singh,
With deep respect for your long service to the Indian Air Force — and with a wink to the theatrics of modern aerial brinkmanship — I write three months after the intense air engagements of May 6–7, 2025.
The subcontinent’s skies have seen many dramas, but in this age of satellite eyes, AI sleuths, and open-source intelligence, claims can’t be left floating like contrails on a windy day. They demand the ballast of evidence.
India harasses diplomats at Pakistan HC in New Delhi
US puts Balochistan armed group in Pakistan on ‘foreign terrorist’ list
Cargo plane catches fire at Chennai airport
For more such Opinions & Blogs, click here.
The S-400 Kill Protocol — What Must Exist
For any genuine S-400 Triumf engagement, a complete, verifiable trail should include:
- 91N6 “Big Bird” radar plots — full track history from detection to intercept
- 92N6 “Grave Stone” fire-control data — lock-on, launch parameters, terminal tracking
- 55K6E command logs — shooter ID, missile type, launch & intercept time, kill code
- IACCS fusion data — AWACS correlation
- Crash-site coordinates & imagery — matching the engagement timeline
This is not optional; it’s the digital signature of the kill. Without it, the claim is a headline, not a fact.
Mob vandalizes tomb of Nawab Abdus Samad outside UP mausoleum
Rahul Gandhi, Opposition Leaders Detained By Police Over Poll Body March
Two Narratives, One Night
On May 9, 2025, Pakistan Air Force’s AVM Aurangzeb Ahmed briefed the media with:
- Exact GPS coordinates of each claimed IAF aircraft loss
- Tail/serial numbers of Rafales, Su-30MKIs, and MiG-29UPGs
- Radar/AEW plots with time-stamped intercept geometry
- Intercepted controller–pilot comms (BRAA calls)
- Crash-site visuals verified
An open dare: “Show your fleet, we’ll show ours.”
By contrast, the IAF’s May 11 briefing made no mention of S-400 kills. Then, on August 9, you announced that the S-400 had destroyed five PAF fighters and one “large aircraft.”
India Issues Notification for Likely Missile Test in Bay of Bengal
IAF to Seek Quick Rafale Deal with France as Squadron Numbers Dip
The Missing Receipts
Your August claim, sir, is missing every element of the S-400 kill protocol.
- No radar plots
- No fire-control logs
- No AWACS correlation
- No crash-site coordinates
- No pilot/call-sign details
And it contradicts an earlier Defence Attaché admission: “We were not allowed to fire.”
3rd ODI: Pakistan to face West Indies tomorrow
Anas al-Sharif, among five journalists killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza
Why It Matters
In this no-nonsense era, where AI platforms like Grok, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, and ChatGPT-5 can cross-check claims against open-source intelligence in minutes, a bold claim without its data trail doesn’t just invite doubt — it invites challenge.
Pakistan’s account may be disputed, but it was timely, detailed, and backed by physical evidence. Yours appeared three months later, unsupported by the standard operational record the S-400 system automatically generates.
My respectful plea:
Release the radar reels, the logs, the coordinates — or reconsider the recount. Big claims need big proof. Until then, the missing S-400 remains the loudest silence in the skies.
Yours in respectful inquiry,
Iqbal Latif – The No-Nonsense Zone
For more such Opinions & Blogs, click here.
Indian vs Pakistani AESA Radars — Capability, Reality, and Combat Testing
National Minorities Day being observed today
2nd phase of receiving hajj applications begins
Couple denied entry at Delhi restaurant over Indian attire; CM takes note
Another British F-35 jet makes emergency landing in Japan weeks after India snag
The write-up has been submitted by Iqbal Latif
Stay tuned to Baaghi TV for more. Download our app for the latest news, updates & interesting content!
